Do You See What I See?

July 4, 2013

Yesterday I read about St. Thomas in my daily reflections on the Saints. Thinking about the Apostle Thomas I started reflecting on the things we believe, because we’ve seen them … and the things we don’t believe, because we haven’t seen them.


Chapinero, Bogota

I look out my apartment windows in the morning and see nice apartment buildings and well maintained gardens. Living in Chapinero, a middle class neighborhood in Bogotá, it would be easy to think that living in Colombia isn’t much different from living in the U.S. I have a comfortable 2-bedroom apartment that I’ve done a reasonable job of furnishing and decorating. I live within walking distance of a variety of stores, including major grocers. Up the street is a military hospital. Down the block in any direction is a university. My office is only two blocks from my apartment. Most of my neighbors can afford to slip away from the city on a holiday weekend either to a family country home or to visit friends or relatives in the countryside. In short, it would be easy for me to spend my time here in Colombia never seeing those who live in poverty … never experiencing the face of poverty … never having a clear sense of the realities of Colombia.

Sleeping on the streets of NYC

Sleeping on the streets of NYC

[Incidentally, this can also be a part of life in a major U.S. city. We can choose to see the poor, homeless, and hungry in our cities or live in relative isolation and pretend that the problem doesn’t exist.]

If I pay attention on my way to the store, 4 blocks from my apartment, I’ll see several homeless people. Some will be asleep on a park bench. Others will be scrounging for food anywhere they can find something. Occasionally, someone will be sitting on the street corner with a cup in hand, jingling their change in hopes that passersby will get the message and drop in another coin. It’s estimated that the number of homeless in Bogotá is 13,000, roughly 6,000 of which are children. Most organizations estimate that although the para-military fighting has been reduced recently by the peace talks (many of the homeless have been displaced by the ongoing war), the number of homeless continues to rise. Children can be seen in the center of the city trying to sell anything of value, stealing, or doing whatever they can to survive. But, their numbers are only the surface of bigger problem. Most homeless children live in the city gutters and only come out at night. In daylight they are subjected to violence, forced to sell drugs, or forced into prostitution. (For the record, thousands of children endure a life of hunger, harassment, sexual abuse and death on the streets of Colombia’s cities.)


A poor neighborhood in Bogota

There are people who have a place they call home, but live in poor conditions and do the best they can to survive. Throughout the day in my neighborhood, women carrying baskets of avocados, bananas, mangoes, or flowers can be seen trying to make a sale. They shout out their presence announcing what they have in their baskets. While it can seem quaint and picturesque to see women carrying baskets of goods, the reality behind their basket is that they are typically unemployed and have used what little money they have to buy a basket of fruit, vegetables, or flowers in hopes of making back a little more than what they invested. HorseIn addition, carts drawn by men or horses can be seen in the streets throughout the day, usually collecting scrap metal or other discarded items that could be recycled somehow to produce a small profit. All live in poor neighborhoods around the city and are simply doing whatever they can to survive and care for their family.

Most of the people around the neighborhood on a daily basis look like average middle class folk. They have jobs, homes, and families. But if you take a good look, you’ll discover that the U.S. and Colombian sense of middle class is significantly different. According to my friends, a typical salary is around $10,000 – $15,000 a year (or $850 – $1,250/month). You might say to yourself, “That sounds fine since it costs less to live in South America.” Yes, there is some truth to that statement, but it’s worth a closer inspection. Food, for example, in Colombia is comparable in price to food in the States. I’m reasonably frugal, and don’t eat much processed food because I have allergies and am happy to cook my own food, and yet my food and general household items expense is about $350 – $400 per month. An average apartment rents for $250 – $300 per month plus occasional building administration fees. Other monthly expenses include cable and internet ($65), water ($20), electricity ($35 – $60), propane ($10), and cell phone ($40). Oops! There goes that $850, before any savings or anything extra … and those figures are based on an individual (me), not a family of 3 or 4.

Here are just a few statistics … which, of course, will vary depending on who is doing the reporting (these are from a variety of sources):

–       Roughly 50% of the population lives below the poverty line

–       Colombia is the third most unequal county, in terms of income inequality, in the Americas after Bolivia and Haiti (while Latin America is the most unequal region in the world)

–       Poverty and inequality affect women, children, Afro-Colombians, Indigenous groups and displaced persons disproportionately

–       32% of those who have work don’t have any formal work contract, nor access to the healthcare system

–       48% of the Colombian work force derives its income from the small-scale “informal economy” such as street vendors (like the women I mentioned above) and garbage recyclers (again, as referenced above)

–       15% of children under six suffer from malnutrition

–       11% of the population is displaced (second largest displaced population in the world … second only to the Sudan, and often described by major social service organizations as an unidentified “humanitarian crisis” in the Americas)

While it’s nice to look out on a sunny morning and see the gardens in the neighborhood, it’s also good to have the opportunity to reflect on Thomas, and Christ’s words to him.

Then Jesus said to Thomas, “Put your finger here and see my hands; and put out your hand, and place it in my side; do not be faithless, but believing.” Thomas answered him, “My Lord and my God!” Jesus said to him, “Have you believed because you have seen me? Blessed are those who have not seen and yet believe.” (John 20: 27-29)

One Response to “Do You See What I See?”

  1. Karen Hotte Says:

    Beautifully put – thanks for this post.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: